Reference Cases

What works.
What doesn’t.

Public reference cases we use to anchor advisory conversations. No invented client logos. No imagined testimonials.

Constructive Cases

Programmes that show what credible AI-enabled service design looks like.

Estonia

Estonia X-Road

A nationwide data exchange layer connecting public and private systems through verified digital identity.

Lesson

Interoperability and digital identity can make services more coherent before advanced AI is added — and AI is far more useful on top of coherent infrastructure than fragmented systems.

Advisory relevance

Reference architecture for public-sector clients exploring foundations for AI-enabled services.

Singapore

Singapore Smart Nation

National programme combining digital public infrastructure, service redesign, and central coordination.

Lesson

Central coordination and digital public infrastructure can support AI-enabled public services — but require explicit safeguards on data, consent, and contestability.

Advisory relevance

Useful reference for government clients designing AI-enabled service delivery at scale.

Finland

Finland AuroraAI

Life-event-based service design that organises support around citizen journeys rather than departmental portals.

Lesson

Shifting from departmental portals to human journeys changes what AI is for — from search assistant to journey orchestrator.

Advisory relevance

Anchors service-design conversations with public-service and NGO clients.

India

IndiaAI Mission

National AI capacity treated as compute, datasets, models, skills, startup finance, applications, and safe/trusted AI.

Lesson

National AI capacity is a stack, not a single decision — and each layer needs its own governance.

Advisory relevance

Useful framing for ministries, regulators, and development institutions.

Cautionary Cases

Patterns to recognise — and design against — before they take root.

Australia

Australia Robodebt

Automated welfare debt inference deployed without lawful, fair, human-centred process.

Failure pattern

Automation of consequential decisions without due process, contestability, or human accountability for harm.

Advisory relevance

Used as a cautionary reference when designing decision rights and non-automation registers.

Netherlands

Netherlands Childcare Benefits Scandal

Risk-scoring and institutional suspicion harmed thousands of families and amplified discrimination.

Failure pattern

Risk models combined with institutional bias and weak contestability cause systemic harm.

Advisory relevance

Reference for algorithmic impact assessments and discrimination audits.

Multiple jurisdictions

Predictive Policing

Predictive systems that direct enforcement based on historical data already shaped by enforcement choices.

Failure pattern

Feedback loops that send enforcement to already over-policed communities and entrench existing patterns.

Advisory relevance

Reference for evaluating any system whose outputs change the inputs it later receives.

Enterprise

Unmanaged Enterprise Copilots

Sensitive data, hallucinated analysis, and inconsistent review spreading through informal AI adoption.

Failure pattern

Tooling deployed without decision rights, evaluation, or audit trails — creating quiet operational and legal exposure.

Advisory relevance

Common starting point for enterprise governance engagements.

We use these cases — and many more — to shape every engagement.

Discuss your context

Made with Emergent